Consommé starts as a full-flavored, rich stock i m sorry is then diminished with egg white skin - man to remove the sediments and also fat. The final result is a clear, intense tasting clarified liquid the is offered as soup because that an appetizer. Developed by the French, consommé is a popular dish that is loved for its taste. It likewise possesses a distinctive viscous texture the is thicker than daily broth.

You are watching: What is beef consomme vs broth

Consommé has a variety uses in cooking. That is the basis because that aspic, a savory jelly containing piece of meat or seafood. That can likewise be used included to casseroles, soups and many other side dishes. Dumplings are taken to a brand-new level as soon as served in a flavor-packed consommé.

If friend are trying to find a beef consommé substitute climate the best options are to usage either beef broth, beef stock, or mushroom consommé. making homemade consommé is also wonderful option if time permits. It might take several hrs of food preparation time, but the final result will be much better than a store-bought product.

Other articles you may be interested in:How to do cheese souffles?What does foie gras taste like?

Table that Contents

Suggested alternatives to beef consomméHow to make beef consommé

Suggested options to beef consommé

1. Beef stock

Beef share is a beneficial replacement for consomme.

Beef share is the finest back-up choice if girlfriend don’t have any consommé in the kitchen. It can be purchase in a packet, such together beef bouillon cubes, i beg your pardon is well if you’re feather to save time. If you have actually time come spare, the homemade alternative will sell a much tastier, flavorsome liquid.

To make homemade stock, you’ll roast 2 pounds that beef bones for 30 minutes. Then add them to a stockpot that water through chopped onions, carrots, celery, and also your favorite herbs. Simmer the bones because that eight hours, enabling the collagen in the skeletal to administer the liquid through a delicious gelatinous texture.

2. Beef broth

Beef broth made from scrape is packed with flavor.

Another suitable alternate to beef consommé is beef broth. That is cooked for a much shorter time 보다 stock.

Although castle both have actually a comparable meaty flavor profile, broth will have actually less intensity. This difference can be addressed by simmering the broth top top a low warmth for 15-30 minutes until it reduces. This cooking procedure will diminish the liquid and increase the flavor.

3. Mushroom consommé

Mushrooms mimic the umami readily available by meat.

If you need a plant-based, vegetarian alternative to utilizing beef, mushroom consommé is a great option. You’ll acquire that delicious umami flavor the would generally come native beef.

If you want to make homemade mushroom consommé, then check out this recipe end at the NY Times. It supplies a mix of new white and porcini mushrooms for included taste.

How to do beef consommé

This is a basic recipe for making beef consommé in ~ home. Because that a much better flavor, consider replacing the store-bought stock through a homemade version. As pointed out above, you’ll require the best part of a day come simmer the bones. It’s worth her time if you have the right to spare it.


4 egg whites1 tsp black pepper4 celery stalks4 little tomatoes, such together Roma¾ lb ground beef, premium sirloin1 ½ tsp salt1 sprig rosemary1 youth thyme6 cups beef stock


Add egg whites and pepper to a huge bowl and also whisk till a foamy texture forms.Pulse the celery, tomatoes, and also ground beef numerous times in a food processor.Combine every the ingredients right into a huge stockpot and heat on high, generally stirring, until boiling. Minimize the warmth to a simmer and enable to cook for 40 minutes. No stirring is required.Remove from heat and also carefully pour the liquid v a fine-mesh sieve the is lined through cheesecloth.Season and serve steaming warm in a bowl or allow it come cool for later on use.
“Stock is every little thing in cooking. Without it, nothing deserve to be done.”

Storage recommendations

Store beef consommé in one airtight container for 3-4 job or frozen the consommé because that up to 6 months. Constantly label food v the date it was created easy freezer management.

How does clarification work?

During the process of slow-cooking stock, protein from the meat transfers right into the water. This outcomes in a cloudy feather liquid. Throughout clarification, this protein coagulates and collects at the optimal of the pan. By carefully filtering the liquid with a cheesecloth, the solids different from the liquid, resulting in a clean stock.

Consomme is excellent for making casseroles.

Final words

Beef consommé is a clear soup that’s fairly time-intensive to do at home, and also not always obtainable in stores. If you’re looking for a an ideal alternative, climate beef share or broth are your best options for replicating a comparable flavor and also texture. Naturally, they won’t perfectly mimic consommé. Consommé changes its type and taste when it is cooked v egg whites for virtually an hour. This step helps come clarify the fluid – reduce the fat and also increasing its viscosity.

If you are looking to replace consommé together a soup, eaten on its own, climate your finest option is to change the menu item. Utilizing an alternate like stock, won’t reduced it as a soup. French onion is an additional rich, flavorsome soup you could want to use instead? inspect out our cooking recipes here.

See more: What Are The Factors Of 256, How To Find The Factors Of 256

For recipes that use beef consommé combined with other ingredients, friend can gain away with using beef share or broth. Because that most, the distinction will barely be noticeable.

Do you gain French food? examine out this articles:Croque mam vs croque monsieur – compare two exceptional French sandwichesFrittata vs quiche – do you recognize the difference?